Goodsurance
ES

Carriers & the market

UnitedHealth, the Largest Medicare Advantage Insurer, Sues CMS Over 2027 Star Ratings

The nation's biggest Medicare Advantage operator filed suit in Texas, contending regulators unfairly docked its plan scores over a single French-language test call placed during the measurement period.

By the Goodsurance editorial teamNovember 20, 2026

UnitedHealth Group became the largest Medicare Advantage insurer to challenge its federal quality scores in court, filing a lawsuit in a Texas district court on November 20, 2026, over how CMS calculated its 2027 star ratings.

The complaint centers on a single test call placed in French by a CMS evaluator. UnitedHealth contends its call center connected the evaluator within the required response window, but that the evaluator never posed the standard introductory question the plan's staff is trained to answer. Because the caller skipped that question, UnitedHealth argues, the representative had no prompt to deliver the required response. Regulators nonetheless marked the interaction as unsatisfactory, the company alleges, lowering scores that in turn affect bonus payments and member plan choices during open enrollment.

UnitedHealth, Medicare's largest Advantage insurer, became at least the 15th plan to sue CMS over 2027 star ratings. The dispute comes down to one French-language test call.

The suit also argues that CMS improperly delegated the call evaluation to a private contractor without clear authorization from Congress, an administrative-law argument similar to claims raised in earlier star-rating challenges by other carriers.

UnitedHealth covers more than 9 million Medicare Advantage members, making it the program's largest single operator by enrollment. A lower star rating can reduce access to quality bonus payments and may influence whether beneficiaries select a plan during the annual open enrollment period, which runs through December 7, 2026.

UnitedHealth is at least the 15th Medicare Advantage plan to sue CMS over 2027 star calculations. Courts ordered CMS to recalculate scores for dozens of plans earlier in 2026 following similar suits, and UnitedHealth has obtained rating corrections in prior cycles through comparable legal arguments.

In plain words

UnitedHealth is the biggest Medicare Advantage insurance company in the country. It covers more than 9 million people. The company sued the government on November 20, 2026, over how Medicare scored its 2027 plan quality grades, called star ratings. The company says a government tester called its customer line in French. The tester never asked the required opening question. Because of that, the call was marked as failing. UnitedHealth says that is not fair. Lower star ratings can cost a plan bonus money and may lead members to choose a different plan during open enrollment, which runs until December 7. At least 14 other Medicare Advantage plans filed similar lawsuits earlier this year.

Source: STAT News
Read at the source →

More news

Other stories on what is moving in Medicare.

Carriers & the market

California Bars a Medicare Advantage Insurer From Taking New Members Weeks Before Open Enrollment Closes

The state health plan regulator issued a cease-and-desist order against Astiva Health over solvency shortfalls, stopping new enrollments as the December 7 deadline nears.

November 13, 2026

Carriers & the market

Aetna Reports Lower Medical Costs in Third Quarter as Medicare Advantage Margins Continue to Recover

CVS Health's quarterly report shows Aetna spent a smaller share of premium on member claims in the period ended September 30, with its Medicare business leading the improvement just weeks into open enrollment for 2027.

November 11, 2026

Carriers & the market

Medicare Advantage Star Ratings Litigation Widens to at Least 10 Insurers as Open Enrollment Continues

Jefferson Health Plans, a university-affiliated plan in Pennsylvania, became among the latest to challenge CMS's 2027 rating methodology in court, joining a legal pileup that now spans plans of every size and type.

November 10, 2026

Carriers & the market

Humana Says 2027 Open Enrollment Is Ahead of Plan and Expects Medicare Advantage Membership to Grow

Weeks after non-renewal notices went out to members in dozens of exited markets, Humana told investors that early annual enrollment period data show better-than-expected retention and new sales, pointing to 2027 membership growth.

November 9, 2026

Carriers & the market

CVS Health Plans to Split Into Two Companies, Keeping Aetna and Caremark Together

The corporate parent of one of the largest Medicare Advantage insurers announced it will separate its insurance and pharmacy benefits arm from its retail drugstores by 2028, reversing roughly a decade of vertical integration.

November 5, 2026

Carriers & the market

Fairview Health Services Sued UnitedHealthcare for Listing It as In-Network in 2027 Medicare Advantage Plans After Exiting the Contract

A Minneapolis health system says UnitedHealthcare's open enrollment materials pointed current members to a provider directory that still included Fairview even after the system ended its contract. The case raises questions about directory accuracy during the annual enrollment window.

November 4, 2026