Policy & oversight
OIG: Conflicting Medicare Rules Allowed an Estimated 380 Million Dollars in Organ Payments Not Required by Federal Law
A federal audit completed September 1 found that CMS guidance permitted reimbursements to certified transplant centers for organs never implanted in Medicare patients, diverging from what federal statute requires.
By the Goodsurance editorial teamSeptember 6, 2026
The Office of Inspector General released audit report OAS-25-07-124 finding that Medicare paid an estimated 380 million dollars over a six-year period for organs acquired by certified transplant centers but never transplanted into Medicare enrollees. The OIG concluded the payments resulted from a conflict between CMS agency guidance and the governing federal statute.
Federal law, as the OIG interprets it, limits Medicare reimbursement for organ acquisition to cases where the organ is actually transplanted into a Medicare-covered beneficiary. CMS guidance, however, allowed transplant centers to bill Medicare for any usable organ they obtained, whether or not it went to a Medicare patient. That gap created conditions in which Medicare bore costs for organs that ultimately served patients covered by other payers.
Medicare paid an estimated 380 million dollars for organs not implanted in Medicare patients, a federal audit found.
The OIG estimated the program-wide cost of the discrepancy at roughly 380 million dollars across the audit window. The watchdog recommended CMS revise its guidance to match statutory requirements and consider steps to address past overpayments.
Transplant centers and organ procurement organizations receive Medicare reimbursement for organ acquisition costs because those costs are not captured in standard hospital billing. The audit does not allege wrongdoing by any transplant center; the OIG attributed the problem to contradictory federal guidance, not provider misconduct.
CMS did not immediately respond publicly to the report, which was published by the OIG on September 1, 2026.
In plain words
A government watchdog reviewed how Medicare pays transplant hospitals for organs. It found that Medicare paid about 380 million dollars over six years for organs that went to patients not covered by Medicare. Federal law says Medicare should only pay for organs used in Medicare patients. But CMS instructions to hospitals allowed broader payments. The watchdog says CMS should update its instructions to match the law.
Understand the basics first
Source: OIG
Read at the source →