Goodsurance
ES

Carriers & the market

Federal Audit Found Most Sampled Medicare Advantage Diagnosis Codes From Priority Health Lacked Medical Record Support

An OIG audit of Priority Health, a Michigan-based Medicare Advantage organization, found that 252 of 300 reviewed enrollee-years had unsupported diagnosis codes, projecting at least 4.4 million dollars in net overpayments for the 2018 and 2019 payment years.

By the Goodsurance editorial teamAugust 18, 2026

The HHS Office of Inspector General completed an audit of Priority Health, a Michigan-based Medicare Advantage organization operating under CMS contract H2320, and found that most of the diagnosis codes the plan submitted for use in risk adjustment calculations were not supported by enrollees' medical records.

Of 300 enrollee-years reviewed, 252 had diagnosis codes that did not meet federal requirements, resulting in 828,010 dollars in estimated net overpayments within the sample. Projecting from the sample to the full population, OIG estimated Priority Health received at least 4.4 million dollars in net overpayments for the 2018 and 2019 payment years.

An OIG audit found Priority Health submitted unsupported Medicare Advantage diagnosis codes in 252 of 300 reviewed cases, with projected net overpayments of at least 4.4 million dollars.

Sepsis codes showed a notable error rate. Of 30 enrollee-years where Priority submitted a sepsis diagnosis, 14 lacked medical record support.

Medicare Advantage risk adjustment pays plans more for members with serious diagnoses, on the theory that sicker enrollees cost more to cover. When a diagnosis cannot be supported by the medical record, the plan may receive payment that does not reflect the patient's actual health status.

OIG recommended that Priority Health refund the overpayments and strengthen internal controls over diagnosis code submissions. The audit is part of OIG's ongoing targeted review of high-risk diagnosis codes submitted by Medicare Advantage organizations nationwide.

In plain words

Government auditors reviewed records at Priority Health, a Medicare Advantage plan in Michigan. In 252 of 300 cases they checked, the codes the plan sent to Medicare did not match the medical records. Medicare pays more for sicker patients, so wrong codes can mean the plan is paid too much. Auditors say the plan may have been overpaid by at least 4.4 million dollars for 2018 and 2019. They told Priority Health to pay back the money and improve its review process.

Source: OIG
Read at the source →

More news

Other stories on what is moving in Medicare.

Carriers & the market

California Bars a Medicare Advantage Insurer From Taking New Members Weeks Before Open Enrollment Closes

The state health plan regulator issued a cease-and-desist order against Astiva Health over solvency shortfalls, stopping new enrollments as the December 7 deadline nears.

November 13, 2026

Carriers & the market

Aetna Reports Lower Medical Costs in Third Quarter as Medicare Advantage Margins Continue to Recover

CVS Health's quarterly report shows Aetna spent a smaller share of premium on member claims in the period ended September 30, with its Medicare business leading the improvement just weeks into open enrollment for 2027.

November 11, 2026

Carriers & the market

Medicare Advantage Star Ratings Litigation Widens to at Least 10 Insurers as Open Enrollment Continues

Jefferson Health Plans, a university-affiliated plan in Pennsylvania, became among the latest to challenge CMS's 2027 rating methodology in court, joining a legal pileup that now spans plans of every size and type.

November 10, 2026

Carriers & the market

Humana Says 2027 Open Enrollment Is Ahead of Plan and Expects Medicare Advantage Membership to Grow

Weeks after non-renewal notices went out to members in dozens of exited markets, Humana told investors that early annual enrollment period data show better-than-expected retention and new sales, pointing to 2027 membership growth.

November 9, 2026

Carriers & the market

CVS Health Plans to Split Into Two Companies, Keeping Aetna and Caremark Together

The corporate parent of one of the largest Medicare Advantage insurers announced it will separate its insurance and pharmacy benefits arm from its retail drugstores by 2028, reversing roughly a decade of vertical integration.

November 5, 2026

Carriers & the market

Fairview Health Services Sued UnitedHealthcare for Listing It as In-Network in 2027 Medicare Advantage Plans After Exiting the Contract

A Minneapolis health system says UnitedHealthcare's open enrollment materials pointed current members to a provider directory that still included Fairview even after the system ended its contract. The case raises questions about directory accuracy during the annual enrollment window.

November 4, 2026