Goodsurance
ES

Agents & how we are paid

Federal Court Allows DOJ Lawsuit Against Three Major Medicare Advantage Insurers and Their Brokers to Proceed

A federal judge ruled in March 2026 that Aetna, Humana, and Elevance Health must face allegations they paid illegal kickbacks to online brokerages to direct Medicare enrollees to their plans, with some payments allegedly tied to limiting sign-ups of people with disabilities.

By the Goodsurance editorial teamAugust 18, 2026

The Department of Justice filed a civil lawsuit in May 2025 against three large Medicare Advantage insurers, Aetna, Humana, and Elevance Health, as well as three large online brokerages, eHealth, GoHealth, and SelectQuote. The case originated as a whistleblower complaint under the False Claims Act, filed in 2021. The DOJ alleged the insurers paid hundreds of millions of dollars in what were labeled marketing funds to the brokerages from 2016 through at least 2021, in exchange for directed enrollments into their plans.

On March 25, 2026, a federal district court in Massachusetts denied a joint motion by all six defendants to dismiss the case. All defendants have denied the allegations and said they plan to fight the claims in court.

A federal judge allowed a DOJ lawsuit to proceed alleging three major Medicare Advantage insurers paid brokers to steer beneficiaries, and allegedly pressured brokers to limit enrollment of people with disabilities.

The lawsuit raises two distinct concerns for Medicare consumers. First, the government alleges that brokers were financially rewarded based on which insurer paid them the most, rather than which plan would best serve a given beneficiary. Second, the DOJ alleges that Aetna and Humana pressured the brokerages to limit enrollment of Medicare beneficiaries with disabilities, whom the insurers reportedly viewed as more costly. If proven, that second allegation would constitute unlawful discrimination.

The case is proceeding in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts. No trial date has been set.

In plain words

The government sued three big Medicare Advantage insurance companies and three large online insurance brokers. The government says the insurers paid the brokers to point seniors toward their plans, rather than toward the best plan for each person. The government also says the insurers pushed brokers to sign up fewer people with disabilities. A judge said the case can move forward. All the companies say the claims are wrong and plan to fight in court.

Source: KFF Health News
Read at the source →

More news

Other stories on what is moving in Medicare.

Agents & how we are paid

Aetna Drops Broker Commissions on 123 Medicare Advantage Plans for 2027 While Open Enrollment Runs

Aetna has designated 123 Medicare Advantage plans across 33 states as non-commissionable for 2027, meaning brokers earn nothing for placing new members in those plans during the current enrollment window, which closes December 7.

October 28, 2026

Agents & how we are paid

FTC Warns Medicare Shoppers That Scammers Are Buying Search Ads to Mimic Official Government Sites

With open enrollment running through December 7, the Federal Trade Commission says dishonest operators are paying to place ads at the top of search results using Medicare.gov-style logos and near-identical web addresses.

October 25, 2026

Agents & how we are paid

Poll: Six in Ten Medicare Enrollees Spend Less Than an Hour Picking a Plan, and Brokers Are the Top Outside Guide

A nationally representative survey published on open enrollment's first day finds most older adults stick with their current plan without fully reviewing options, and that insurance brokers are the most commonly cited outside information source.

October 15, 2026

Agents & how we are paid

With Open Enrollment Days Away, MedPAC Report Flags Overwhelming Choices and Agent Incentive Concerns

A chapter in MedPAC's June 2026 Report to Congress documented the difficulty beneficiaries face when choosing Medicare plans and raised questions about whether agents are fully aligned with beneficiary interests.

October 11, 2026

Agents & how we are paid

Aetna Will Pay No Broker Commissions on 123 Medicare Advantage Plans Across 33 States During 2027 Open Enrollment

The CVS Health subsidiary notified third-party marketing organizations of the freeze, covering plans in nearly 780 counties, just weeks before the October annual enrollment period.

August 21, 2026

Agents & how we are paid

Medicare Agents Can Meet With You the Same Day You Sign the Appointment Form Starting October 1

A CMS rule taking effect October 1 eliminates the 48-hour waiting period between completing a Scope of Appointment and discussing Medicare Advantage or Part D plans, changing how the fall enrollment season will feel for people shopping for coverage.

August 11, 2026