Goodsurance

Medicare Advantage

Nursing Home Star Ratings on Care Compare Were Recalculated in July 2026 With Tougher Benchmarks

CMS raised the quality measure thresholds nursing homes must clear to earn higher star ratings, so some facilities may show different scores on Care Compare even if the care they provide has not changed.

By the Goodsurance editorial teamJuly 13, 2026

CMS updated its Nursing Home Five-Star Quality Rating System in July 2026, raising the benchmarks nursing homes must meet to earn higher quality measure ratings. With this quarterly refresh, CMS increased each quality measure rating threshold by one half of the average improvement in quality measure scores observed across nursing homes from January 2025 through April 2026.

The five-star system rates each nursing home across three components: health inspection results, staffing levels, and quality measures. Each component receives its own one-to-five star score, and those feed into the overall rating visible on Care Compare at medicare.gov.

CMS raised the bar for nursing home star ratings in July 2026. Scores may have changed at facilities where care did not.

Because CMS periodically raises thresholds as national nursing home performance improves, a facility that maintained the same standard of care as the prior year could see a lower quality measure score if it did not outpace the broader industry trend. Conversely, facilities that improved faster than average may see their scores rise.

For Medicare beneficiaries, including those in Medicare Advantage plans, who are comparing nursing facilities for a planned or emergency stay, checking each component score on Care Compare offers more detail than the overall star count alone. The July 2026 rating update coincides with a separate CMS initiative, announced the same week, to implement risk-based survey scheduling for inspections.

In plain words

CMS updated the star ratings for nursing homes in July 2026. To earn the same number of stars as before, a nursing home now has to score higher. The bar was raised because the average quality across all nursing homes has gone up. Some nursing homes may show fewer stars even though their care did not get worse. If you are looking for a nursing home on medicare.gov, check all three scores separately, not just the overall star. The scores cover inspections, staffing, and quality of care.

Understand the basics first

Source: CMS
Read at the source →

More news

Other stories on what is moving in Medicare.

Medicare Advantage

The 2026 Count of Hospital Systems Dropping Medicare Advantage Contracts Reaches at Least 30, With October 1 Exits Days Before Open Enrollment

A running tracker updated September 22 shows the year's hospital-insurer separations still accumulating, with multiple contract exits taking effect October 1, just two weeks before the annual enrollment window opens.

September 24, 2026

Medicare Advantage

Federal Watchdog Found the Three Largest Medicare Advantage Plans Denied Long-Term Hospital and Rehab Admissions at the Highest Rates

An OIG data brief from June 2026 found those plans also used outside contractors to issue denials, and many of those contractor decisions were later reversed by the plan itself on appeal.

September 22, 2026

Medicare Advantage

Federal Watchdog Will Examine How Medicare Advantage Plans Require Prior Authorization for Doctor-Administered Drugs

The Office of Inspector General added an evaluation of Medicare Advantage prior authorization for Part B drugs to its work plan, a category covering infused and injected treatments given in physician offices.

September 17, 2026

Medicare Advantage

About Half of the Performance Thresholds Used to Score Medicare Advantage Plans for 2027 Star Ratings Have Risen, Preliminary Data Shows

CMS shared a second round of preliminary 2027 star rating data with Medicare Advantage plans this month, and roughly half of the scoring thresholds are harder to meet than in prior years. Official star ratings are due in early October, just before open enrollment begins October 15.

September 12, 2026

Medicare Advantage

KFF: Medicare Advantage Plans Deny Post-Acute Care Prior Authorization Requests at Rates Far Above the Overall Average

New KFF analysis of mandatory public data found that denial rates for nursing facility, home health, and rehabilitation requests in Medicare Advantage significantly exceed the program-wide average.

September 10, 2026

Medicare Advantage

Medicare Advantage Enrollment Tops 55 Percent in 2026, but the Two Largest Insurers Are Cutting Their County Presence

A KFF analysis finds 35.2 million Medicare beneficiaries are now in Medicare Advantage, up 1.1 million since early 2025, while UnitedHealthcare and Humana each exit roughly 200 counties.

September 8, 2026