Pet insurance · Cornerstone
Pet insurance: how it works, what it covers, and what it costs
Last reviewed October 12, 202610 min readBy the Goodsurance editorial team Reviewed by the Goodsurance editorial team
Pet insurance pays you back for vet bills when your dog or cat gets hurt or sick. You pay the vet first. Then you send a claim, and the insurer pays back part of the bill. This guide shows how pet insurance works, the three plan types, what is left out, what it costs, and how to compare plans.
1Pet insurance in 30 seconds
If you only read one part of this page, read this.
Pet insurance in 30 seconds
You pay the vet, then get paid back
Most plans pay you back after the visit. They do not pay the vet for you.
Three plan types
Accident-only, accident and illness, and a wellness add-on for routine care.
Problems your pet already has are not covered
Buy while your pet is young and healthy to get the most coverage.
Compare more than the price
Look at the deductible, the share paid back, the yearly limit, and what is left out.
2How pet insurance works
Pet insurance works a lot like health insurance, with one big difference. In most cases, you pay the vet yourself. Then the insurer pays you back. The NAIC, the group of state insurance regulators, says most policies pay this way.
Three numbers decide how much you get back:
Deductible. The part of the bill you pay before the plan pays. Most plans use a yearly deductible. Some charge it again for each new problem.
Reimbursement. The share of the bill the plan pays back after the deductible. Common choices are 70%, 80%, and 90%.
Yearly limit. The most the plan will pay in one policy year. Some plans offer no limit.
An example. Say the vet bill is $1,000, your deductible is $250, and your plan pays 80%. Take off the deductible, and $750 is left. The plan pays 80% of that, so you get $600 back. Some insurers take off your share first and then the deductible, which pays a bit less. Ask which way your plan does it.
How a pet insurance claim works
NAIC: "Most policies pay on a reimbursement basis." A few insurers can pay the vet if you set it up ahead of time.
3The three types of pet insurance plans
Accident-only plans pay for injuries, like a broken leg or a swallowed sock. They cost the least. But they do not pay for illness, which causes many of the biggest vet bills.
Accident and illness plans pay for injuries and for new illnesses, like infections, allergies, and cancer. This is the most common kind of plan.
Wellness coverage is an add-on for routine care, like checkups, shots, and flea and tick medicine. It is more like a budget plan than insurance, since you use it every year. Add it only if it pays back more than it costs for the care your pet already gets.
| What it pays for | Accident-only | Accident and illness | Accident and illness plus wellness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Injuries: broken bones, cuts, swallowed objects, poison | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Illness: infections, allergies, cancer, diabetes | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Routine care: checkups, shots, flea and tick meds | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ |
| Problems your pet already had | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
| Average yearly cost for a dog | $190 | $836 | $1,414 |
| Average yearly cost for a cat | $112 | $435 | $859 |
Costs: NAPHIA State of the Industry 2026, average US yearly premiums for 2025. The third column is plans with wellness built in. Your price depends on your pet and your choices.
4What pet insurance usually does not cover
The biggest gap is pre-existing conditions. That means any problem your pet had signs of before coverage started. The NAIC says most pet insurers leave these out. Many also leave out hereditary or birth defects, so check each plan.
Some plans give a second chance. If a curable problem, like an ear infection, goes 12 months with no signs or treatment, it may be covered again. Ask how long the plan requires.
Watch for two-sided problems too. Knees are the common case. If one knee was hurt before, some plans will not cover the other knee for the same problem.
What pet insurance usually covers, and what it leaves out
Covers
- New injuries, from the first day in most plans
- New illnesses, after a short waiting period
- Tests, surgery, hospital stays, and medicine
- Routine care, only if you buy a wellness add-on
Does not cover
- Pre-existing conditions: anything your pet showed signs of before coverage started
- Problems that start during the waiting period
- Cosmetic and elective procedures, breeding, and pregnancy
- Often: exam fees, pet food, and training
Every policy has its own list. Read the sample policy before you buy.
5What pet insurance costs
In 2025, the average accident and illness plan cost $836 a year for a dog and $435 a year for a cat. That is about $70 a month for a dog and about $36 a month for a cat. These averages come from NAPHIA, the pet insurance trade group.
What drives your price. The NAIC lists the main factors: species, breed, sex, age, and where you live. Then come your choices: the deductible, the share paid back, and the yearly limit.
- Dogs cost more than cats. The averages above show it.
- Price goes up with age. Older pets get sick more often.
- Some breeds cost more. Breeds prone to joint, breathing, or back problems carry more risk.
- Where you live matters. Prices follow local vet costs.
- Your choices matter. A higher deductible or a lower limit lowers the price.
6Waiting periods and your rights
A waiting period is the time after you buy before some coverage starts. It stops people from buying a plan after a pet gets sick.
In 2022, the NAIC wrote a model pet insurance law. States that adopt it set the same basic rules:
- No waiting period for accidents.
- No more than 30 days of waiting for illness and joint problems.
- The policy must let a vet exam waive the wait.
- At least 15 days to look over a new policy and return it for a refund.
Not every state has this law. Where it is missing, some plans wait 6 months for hip and knee problems. Your state insurance department can tell you which rules apply.
7How to compare pet insurance plans
Do not compare plans on the monthly price alone. Two plans with the same price can pay very different amounts. Use this checklist, and read each sample policy before you buy. The policy, not the ad, decides what gets paid.
Does any pet insurance cover 100%? Even a plan that pays back 100% still leaves you the deductible, anything over the yearly limit, and anything the policy leaves out. So no plan pays every vet bill in full.
How to compare pet insurance plans
Deductible: how much, and how often?
A yearly deductible is paid once a year. A per-condition deductible is paid again for each new problem.
Share paid back: 70%, 80%, or 90%?
More back means a higher price. Also ask which comes off first: your share or the deductible.
Yearly limit: is it high enough?
One surgery or cancer care can cost thousands. A low limit can leave you with the rest of the bill.
Waiting periods: how long for illness and joints?
Some plans wait 6 months for hip and knee problems. Ask if a vet exam can shorten it.
Exclusions: what is left out?
Check exam fees, dental disease, behavior care, and conditions tied to breed. Ask what happens if one knee was hurt before.
Claims: how and how fast?
Find out the claim deadline, how long payment takes, and whether the insurer can ever pay the vet.
Refund window: can you change your mind?
States with the model law give at least 15 days to return a new policy for a refund.
If your pet reaches the plan's yearly limit before treatment ends, you pay the rest yourself. For cancer care or back surgery, that can be the big bill insurance was meant to stop. A higher limit costs more but lowers that risk.
8How a few insurers set up their plans
What is the best pet insurance? No one plan is right for every pet. The right one covers what your pet is likely to need, at a price you can keep paying. Here is how three insurers differ on a few points, from their own websites.
For a closer look at one company, read our Fetch pet insurance review. Before you buy from any insurer, check that it is licensed in your state with the NAIC company search.
| What you get | Fetch | Healthy Paws | ASPCA Pet Health Insurance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plans sold | One accident and illness plan, plus a wellness add-on | One accident and illness plan. No preventive care. | Complete Coverage or Accident-Only, plus a preventive add-on |
| Pays back up to | 90% | 90% | 90% |
| Sick-visit exam fees | ✓ | ✗ | Yes, on Complete Coverage |
| A "no yearly limit" choice | Not online. Ask by phone. | ✓ | Not listed on its home page |
| Can pay the vet for you | ✗ | Yes, if you set it up ahead of time | Not on its home page. You pay, then claim. |
Not a ranking. Each cell comes from that company's own website, checked October 12, 2026. Prices depend on your pet, so get a quote from each one.
9Is pet insurance worth it?
It depends on two things: the risk your pet carries, and what you would do if a big bill came.
Start with what owners spend now. The average dog-owning home spends $598 a year at the vet, and a cat-owning home spends $529. In many years, a healthy pet's bills will be less than the premium.
But insurance is for the bad year. One emergency surgery or a cancer diagnosis can cost many times the yearly average. If you could pay a bill like that from savings, a pet savings fund may work for you. If you could not, insurance turns a surprise bill into a set monthly cost.
Timing matters most. A young, healthy pet has no pre-existing conditions, so a plan bought early covers the most. For more, see is pet insurance worth it?
The vast majority of US pet owners pay all vet costs on their own.
10More pet insurance guides
Each guide answers one question in depth.
Choosing a plan
- Best pet insurance: 10 companies compared, line by line
- How to compare pet insurance: a side-by-side method and worksheet
- How much is pet insurance? Average costs for dogs and cats
- Cheap pet insurance: honest ways to pay less, and when cheap is a trap
How coverage works
- Pet insurance deductible, reimbursement and limits: how the math works
- Pet insurance waiting periods: how long until coverage starts
- Pet insurance that pays the vet directly: who offers it and how it works
- How to file a pet insurance claim, how long it takes, and what to do if it is denied
- Pet insurance laws by state: who has rules and what they say
What it covers
Your pet
Common questions about Pet
Quick answers to common questions
Tap any question to expand. Each question links to a fuller standalone answer.
How much does pet insurance typically cost?
In 2025, the average accident and illness plan cost $836 a year for a dog and $435 a year for a cat, per NAPHIA. Accident-only plans averaged $190 for dogs and $112 for cats. Your price depends on your pet's species, breed, age, where you live, and the choices you make.
Is pet insurance really worth the money?
It is worth it if a large vet bill would be hard for you to pay. In a calm year, premiums may cost more than your vet bills. In a bad year, one surgery can cost far more than the premiums. It is worth the most when you buy before your pet has any health problems.
Do any pet insurance plans cover 100%?
No plan pays every bill in full. Many let you choose 70%, 80%, or 90% back. Even at 100%, you would still pay the deductible, costs over the yearly limit, and anything the policy leaves out.
What is the best pet insurance?
No single plan is best for every pet. Compare the deductible, the share paid back, the yearly limit, the waiting periods, and the exclusions. Then get quotes for your own pet. Our company reviews, like our Fetch review, can help.
How does pet insurance work?
You take your pet to any licensed vet and pay the bill. Then you send the bill and records to the insurer. It takes off your deductible and your share, and pays you the rest, up to your yearly limit.
Does pet insurance cover pre-existing conditions?
Usually not. Problems your pet showed signs of before coverage started are left out. Some plans will cover a curable problem again after a set time with no signs, often 12 months.
Is there a waiting period for pet insurance?
Yes, for illness. In states with the model pet insurance law, it can be no more than 30 days, and accidents have no wait. Some plans wait longer for hip and knee problems where the law does not apply.
Does pet insurance cover routine care like shots?
Not on its own. Routine care like checkups, shots, and flea and tick medicine needs a wellness add-on, which costs extra.
Can I use any vet?
Often, yes. Many plans, like Fetch, let you use any licensed vet in the US. Check the policy to be sure.
Can I cancel if I change my mind?
In states with the model pet insurance law, you get at least 15 days to return a new policy for a refund. Some insurers give longer. Check the policy for the exact rule.
References
- NAIC: Pet insuranceHow pet insurance works, plan types, common exclusions, and the NAIC Pet Insurance Model Act.
- NAPHIA: State of the Industry 2026, HighlightsAverage yearly premiums by plan type for dogs and cats, and the share of US pets insured (2025 data).
- AVMA: US pet ownership statisticsUS dog and cat counts, and average yearly vet spending by household.
- US Bureau of Economic Analysis via FRED: Spending on petsUS consumer spending on pets, pet products, and services.
- Rhode Island General Laws 27-83-4: Pet insurance policy conditionsAn enacted version of the model law: waiting period limits and exam waivers.
- Washington SB 5319 final bill reportModel law rules, including the 15-day free look.
- NAIC: State insurance departmentsFind your state regulator to check rules and file a complaint.
- NAIC: Consumer Insurance SearchCheck that an insurance company is licensed.
- Fetch: Can I customize my pet insurance plan?An example of 70%, 80%, and 90% reimbursement choices.
- Fetch: Sample pet insurance policy (GPTM 050 0326 A)An example of how a policy sets the order of the deductible and your share.
- Healthy Paws: Coverage and exclusionsUsed for the company comparison table.
- ASPCA Pet Health Insurance: PlansUsed for the company comparison table.